How to Get the Toughest Restaurant Reservations in New York

In a city where every meal can feel like an event, landing a table at New York’s most coveted restaurants is a skill. From sushi counters with six seats to buzzy brasseries booked months in advance, navigating the reservation scene takes strategy, flexibility, and just a little bit of luck.

With TravelPal.ai, you can build a full NYC itinerary—including dining at hard-to-book spots—without the stress of endless planning.

Why Some NYC Restaurants Are So Hard to Book

Scarcity, hype, and size often drive exclusivity. A handful of Michelin-starred spots only offer a limited number of seatings per night. Others gain viral fame from TikTok, creating a frenzy of demand. And some—like Rao’s or Bohemian—are practically invitation-only, fueling the mystique even more.

Tips to Score a Table at Hotspots

1. Plan Weeks (or Months) Ahead

Many top NYC restaurants release tables 30 days in advance—some even 60. Set calendar reminders and book the moment they open.

2. Use Reservation Tools Wisely

Platforms like Resy, Tock, and OpenTable offer alerts. Use the “notify” or “watch” feature for your preferred date and time.

3. Be Flexible With Dates and Times

Avoid Friday/Saturday nights. Consider early seatings, late-night dinners, or even weekday lunches. A little flexibility goes a long way.

4. Try the Bar or Walk-In List

Many trendy spots hold bar seats or counter space for walk-ins. Arrive early and be ready to wait—especially at smaller places.

5. Leverage Concierge Services or Credit Card Perks

Amex Platinum, Chase Sapphire Reserve, and hotel concierges often have access to exclusive tables. TravelPal’s concierge can help make those calls for you too.

6. Know When to Refresh

Canceled reservations often pop up 24-48 hours in advance. Check at odd hours or refresh the app frequently—especially early in the morning or late at night.

A Few of NYC’s Toughest Tables

• Rao’s – Harlem’s iconic Italian spot, known for being invite-only.
• Bohemian – Hidden behind a butcher shop, and only accessible via referral.
• Dame – Greenwich Village seafood hotspot with limited seats and fast-booking drops.
• Lucali – Pizza worth the wait in Carroll Gardens—no reservations, just get there early.
• Kochi – Michelin-starred Korean skewers in Hell’s Kitchen.
• Tatiana by Kwame Onwuachi – Vibrant Afro-Caribbean flavors at Lincoln Center.
• Don Angie – Italian-American with a cult following and almost impossible primetime slots.

Bonus: Use These NYC Hotlines, Apps & Hacks

• Last-minute apps like Appointment Trader or Seated sometimes unlock spots—for a fee.
• Instagram: Restaurants sometimes announce cancellations in Stories.
• Call Direct: Old-school, but some places still prefer a phone call over digital platforms.

Make It Part of a Bigger Experience

Don’t just book dinner—build your whole evening around it. Pair a reservation at Kochi with a Broadway show. Pre-game a Lucali wait with drinks at Barely Disfigured. Follow up Tatiana with jazz at Dizzy’s Club. A great reservation becomes even better when part of a night to remember.

Plan a trip to New York City today with TravelPal.ai.