Best For
Indulgent breakfasts, legendary key lime pie, and soaking up the quirky Key West atmosphere.
US
Caribbean Restaurant·Eclectic, Relaxed, Funky, Tropical
Blue Heaven is more than just a restaurant; it’s a Key West institution that perfectly captures the island's laid-back, eclectic spirit. Guests can dine indoors in a charmingly decorated space or outdoors under a canopy of trees, often accompanied by local roosters and live jazz music. The menu is a vibrant mix of Caribbean and American influences, featuring standouts like lobster benedict, jerk chicken, and fresh mahi-mahi. No visit is complete without tasting their legendary key lime pie, known for its massive meringue and perfectly tart filling. Whether you're there for a boozy brunch or a relaxed dinner, the atmosphere is consistently warm and nostalgic.
Blue Heaven is more than just a restaurant; it’s a Key West institution that perfectly captures the island's laid-back, eclectic spirit. Guests can dine indoors in a charmingly decorated space or outdoors under a canopy of trees, often accompanied by local roosters and live jazz music. The menu is a vibrant mix of Caribbean and American influences, featuring standouts like lobster benedict, jerk chicken, and fresh mahi-mahi. No visit is complete without tasting their legendary key lime pie, known for its massive meringue and perfectly tart filling. Whether you're there for a boozy brunch or a relaxed dinner, the atmosphere is consistently warm and nostalgic.
You might want to ask
Address
729 Thomas St,Key West, FL 33040, USA
Websiteblueheavenkw.com
Phone(305) 296-8666
Hours
ClosedDaily 8:00 AM - 2:30 PM, 5:00 - 10:00 PM
Highlights
Famous towering key lime pie with massive, fluffy meringue.
Live jazz music providing a soulful island backdrop.
Whimsical outdoor seating shared with local roosters.
Fresh seafood specialties like lobster benedict and mahi-mahi.
Creative cocktails including a signature key lime martini.
Time of Day
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Late Night
Occasion Tags
Casual Dining, Tourists, Locals, Brunch, Special Occasion
Reviews
4.6
Excellent11,9 K reviews
Blue Heaven is a beloved Key West landmark that consistently earns high praise for its vibrant Caribbean-American menu and unique, funky atmosphere. Reviewers frequently highlight the key lime pie as a standout, often describing it as the best they've ever had due to its massive meringue and balanced tartness. The breakfast and brunch offerings, particularly the lobster benedict and blueberry pancakes, are highly recommended. The setting is described as eclectic and quintessentially Key West, featuring outdoor dining with roaming roosters and live jazz music that adds to the lively vibes. While the service is generally lauded as friendly and professional, many guests note that wait times can be quite long, especially during peak periods. Despite the crowds, the restaurant remains a nostalgic favorite for many, offering a sense of peace and island charm.
Add dates for experiences
Location
Key West, Florida, United States
