Keep exploring with TravelPal
Enter your email to sign up or log in.
Sign up and get $5 free credit
or
Tucked away on the east side of St. Thomas in Frydenhoj, Carigas Island Cafe is a beloved destination for those seeking authentic island flavors and American comfort. Despite its unassuming roadside appearance, the interior offers a warm and inviting escape. The menu features standout items like the Grouper Reuben, fresh wahoo tacos, and tuna bites, alongside a highly-regarded brunch served until 2:00 PM. Guests are encouraged to check the daily specials board for creative, generously-sized dishes like the crispy chicken and pancakes. With its fair pricing and friendly staff, it has earned a reputation as a must-visit spot for both locals and tourists exploring the area near Red Hook.
Carigas Island Cafe is celebrated for its exceptional food quality and warm, friendly service. Reviewers consistently highlight the Grouper Reuben, wahoo tacos, and tuna bites as standout menu items. The brunch menu is also a significant draw, with specific praise for the Barbacoa Scramble and French toast, though guests should note it ends at 2:00 PM. The atmosphere is described as cozy and inviting, making it a favorite for both locals and tourists. Many visitors appreciate the fair pricing, which is often noted as being more affordable than other dining options on St. Thomas. Overall, it is regarded as a hidden gem that delivers a high-quality, authentic island dining experience.
USD $
Moderate
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Casual Drinks, Locals, Tourists, Groups
