Best For
Authentic New York slices with a high-quality, retro vibe.
US
Pizza Restaurant·Retro, Buzzy, Efficient
Scarr's Pizza has earned its reputation as a New York staple by elevating the classic slice with premium ingredients and house-milled flour. Located in the heart of the Lower East Side, the shop features a distinctive retro look that transports visitors back to the 1970s. The menu features fan favorites like the 'Hotboi' slice and vodka pesto, all served on a crust known for its perfect char and cracker-like undercarriage. Despite its popularity and the frequent lines out the door, the service is remarkably fast and efficient. It is an ideal spot for a quick, high-quality bite or a casual meal paired with a canned cocktail.
Scarr's Pizza has earned its reputation as a New York staple by elevating the classic slice with premium ingredients and house-milled flour. Located in the heart of the Lower East Side, the shop features a distinctive retro look that transports visitors back to the 1970s. The menu features fan favorites like the 'Hotboi' slice and vodka pesto, all served on a crust known for its perfect char and cracker-like undercarriage. Despite its popularity and the frequent lines out the door, the service is remarkably fast and efficient. It is an ideal spot for a quick, high-quality bite or a casual meal paired with a canned cocktail.
Highlights
House-milled flour used for a signature charred crust.
Popular 'Hotboi' slice featuring spicy pepperoni and honey.
Nostalgic 1970s-style interior and atmosphere.
Efficient service that handles long lines with impressive speed.
Reviews
4.4
Great4,7 K reviews
Scarr's Pizza is widely celebrated for serving an authentic New York slice that balances tradition with high-quality, modern ingredients. Reviewers frequently highlight the 'Hotboi' slice as a standout for its spicy flavor, though some mention it can occasionally be greasy. The crust is a major draw, described as having a perfect char and a satisfyingly cracker-like texture. The staff is often called 'superhuman' for their ability to move through long lines with incredible speed and efficiency. While the retro-styled space is often crowded and busy, the high-energy atmosphere and quality of the food make it a favorite for both locals and tourists. Overall, it offers a quintessential Lower East Side experience that many claim lives up to the significant hype.
Address
35 Orchard St,New York, NY 10002, USA
Websitescarrspizza.com
Phone(212) 334-3481
Hours
Closing soonMon
11:30 AM - 11:00 PM
Tue
11:30 AM - 11:00 PM
Wed
11:30 AM - 11:00 PM
Thu
11:30 AM - 11:00 PM
Fri
11:30 AM - 1:00 AM
Sat
11:30 AM - 1:00 AM
Sun
11:30 AM - 11:00 PM
Dietary Options
vegetarian-friendly
Time of Day
Lunch, Dinner, Late Night
Occasion Tags
Tourists, Locals, Casual Drinks, Solo
Add dates for experiences
Location
Manhattan, New York, United States
